An Exercise in Theoretical Archaeology: Do Archaeological Cultures Exist?

  • Marko Porčić Department of Archaeology Faculty of Philosophy University of Belgrade
Keywords:
archaeological theory, archaeological culture, typology, evolutionism

Abstract

Archaeological culture still persists as a basic analytical and interpretative concept in Serbian archaeology despite criticism. This paper presents a formal view of archaeological cultures and explores the epistemological implications of this formalization. Formal analysis of archaeological culture is achieved through logical and quantitative explication of the traditional definition of archaeological cultures. The main result of the formal analysis is that there are real patterns of formal variability of material culture that may or may not correspond to traditional archaeological cultures. These patterns are real only in the analytical sense – they are real for given input data and scale of analysis. Unlike the traditional approach where this patterns are equated with archaeological cultures which are furthered interpreted in essentialist terms or as quasi- organic entities such as ethnic groups, it is claimed here that discovered patterns are only the starting point – the empirical situation that needs to be accounted for in anthropological an historical terms. This paper shows how patterns that are traditionally identified as archaeological cultures can arise as a consequence of an entire range of processes – different social and historical realities. The main conclusion is that the traditional concept of archaeological culture is not useful neither as analytical or interpretative tools for two reasons: 1) traditional cultures are subjectively defined entities with no theoretical justification for the criteria used in their definition and 2) the empirical pattern cannot be an explanation in itself because it is the thing that needs to be explained. Cultural evolutionary (transmission) theory is proposed as a general framework for defining and interpreting patterns of formal variability of material culture in time and space.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Axelrod, Robert. 1997. The Dissemination of Culture: A Model with Local Convergence and Global Polarization. The Journal of Conflict Resolution 41(2): 203-226.
Baxter, Mike J. 2003. Statistics in Archaeology. London: Hodder Arnold.
Bentley, R. Alexander, Matthew W. Hahn and Stephen J. Shennan 2004. Random Drift and Culture Change. Proceedings: Biological Sciences 271(1547): 1443-1450.
Bentley, R. Alexander, Carl P. Lipo, Harold A. Herzog and Matthew W. Hahn. 2007. Regular rates of popular culture change reflect random copying. Evolution and Human Behavior 28(3): 151-158.
Binford, Lewis R. 1977. "General Introduction". In For Theory Building in Archaeology: Essays on Faunal Remains, Aquatic Resources, Spatial Analysis, and Systemic Modeling, ed. Lewis R. Binford, 1-13. New York: Academic Press.
Binford, Lewis R. 1981. Bones: Ancient Men and Modern Myths. New York: Academic Press.
Binford, Lewis R. 1983a. In Pursuit of the Past. New York: Academic Press.
Binford, Lewis R. 1983b. Working at Archaeology. New York: Academic Press.
Binford, Lewis R. 1987. "Researching Ambiguity: Frames of Reference and Site Structure". In Method and Theory for Activity Area Research, ed. Susan Kent, 449-512. New York: Columbia University Press.
Boyd, Robert and Peter J. Richerson. 1985. Culture and the Evolutionary Process. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Cavalli-Sforza, Luigi Luca and Marcus W. Feldman. 1981. Cultural Transmission and Evolution: A Quantiative Approach. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Cavalli-Sforza, Luigi Luca. 2001. Genes, Peoples and Languages. London: Penguin Books.
Clarke, David L. 1968. Analytical Archaeology. London: Methuen & Co.
Deetz, James. 1968. "The inference of residence and descent rules from archeological data". In New perspectives in archeology, ed. Sally R. Binford and Lewis R. Binford, 41-48. Chicago: Aldine.
Dimitrijević, Stojan. 1979. "Sjeverna zona: neolit u centralnom i zapadnom delu sjeverne Jugoslavije". U Praistorija jugoslavenskih zemalja 2: neolit, ur. Alojz Benac, 229-360. Sarajevo: ANUBiH – Svjetlost.
Dokins, Ričard. 2010. Sebični gen. Smederevo: Heliks.
Dunnell, Robert C. 1970. Seriation Method and Its Evaluation. American Antiquity 35(3): 305-319.
Dunnell, Robert C. 1978. Style and Function: A Fundamental Dichotomy. American Antiquity 43(2): 192-202.
Dunnell, Robert C. 1980. "Evolutionary Theory and Archaeology". In Advances in Archaeological Method and Theory, ed. Michael B. Schiffer, 35-99. Vol. 3. New York: Academis Press.
Dunnell, Robert C. 1982. The Harvey Lecture Series. Science, Social Science, and Common Sense: The Agonizing Dilemma of Modern Archaeology. Journal of Anthropological Research 38(1): 1-25.
Džonson, Metju. 2008. Arheološka teorija. Beograd: Clio.
Garašanin, Milutin. 1979. "Centralnobalkanska zona". U Praistorija jugoslavenskih zemalja 2: neolit, ur. A. Benac, 79-212. Sarajevo: ANUBiH – Svetlost.
Guglielmino, C. R., C. Viganotti, B. Hewlett and L. L. Cavalli-Sforza. 1995. Cultural Variation in Africa: Role of Mechanisms of Transmission and Adaptation. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 92(16): 7585-7589.
Hahn, Matthew W. and R. Alexander Bentley. 2003. Drift as a mechanism for cultural change: an example from baby names. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences 270(Suppl 1): 120-123.
Hart, John P. 2012. The effects of geographical distances on pottery assemblage similarities: a case study from Northern Iroquoia. Journal of Archaeological Science 39(1): 128-134.
Hart, JohnP and William Engelbrecht. 2012. Northern Iroquoian Ethnic Evolution: A Social Network Analysis. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory 19(2): 322-349.
Henrich, Joseph. 2001. Cultural Transmission and the Diffusion of Innovations: Adoption Dynamics Indicate That Biased Cultural Transmission Is the Predominate Force in Behavioral Change. American Anthropologist 103(4): 992-1013.
Henrich, Joseph. 2004. Demography and Cultural Evolution: How Adaptive Cultural Processes can Produce Maladaptive Losses: The Tasmanian Case. American Antiquity 69(2): 197-214.
Herzog, Harold A., R. Alexander Bentley and Matthew W. Hahn. 2004. Random Drift and Large Shifts in Popularity of Dog Breeds. Proceedings of The Royal Society: Biological Sciences 271: S353-S356.
Hewlett, Barry S., Annalisa De Silvestri and C. Rosalba Guglielmino. 2002. Semes and Genes in Africa. Current Anthropology 43(2): 313-321.
Hill, James A. 1970. A prehistoric community in eastern Arizona. Southwestern Journal of Anthropology 22: 9-30.
Hodder, Ian. 1977. The Distribution of Material Culture Items in the Baringo District, Western Kenya. Man 12: 239-269.
Jordan, Peter and Thomas Mace. 2008. "Gendered Technology, Kinship, and Cultural Transmission among Salish-Speaking Communities on the Pacific Northwest Coast: A Preliminary Investigation". In Cultural Transmission and Material Culture: Breaking Down Boundaries, ed. Miriam T. Stark, Brenda J. Bowser and Lee Horne, 34-62. Tucson: University of Arizona Press.
Jordan, Peter and Stephen Shennan. 2003. Cultural transmission, language, and basketry traditions amongst the California Indians. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 22(1): 42-74.
Jovanović, Borislav. 1979. "Indoevropljani i eneolitski period Jugoslavije". U Praistorija jugoslavenskih zemalja 3: eneolit, ur. Alojz Benac, 397-416. Sarajevo: ANUBiH – Svjetlost.
Kuzmanović, Zorica. 2009. Upotreba etnografskih analogija u arheološkom zaključivanju. Etnoantropološki problemi 4(1): 133-148.
Lipo, Carl P. 2001. Science, Style and the Study of Community Structure. Oxford: BAR.
Lipo, Carl P., Mark E. Madsen, Robert C. Dunnell and Tim Hunt. 1997. Population Structure, Cultural Transmission, and Frequency Seriation. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 16 (4): 301-333.
Longacre, William A. 1970. Archaeology as anthropology, a case study. Anthtropological Papers 17. Tucson: The University of Arizona Press.
Lyman, Robert L., Michael J. O'Brien and Robert C. Dunnell. 1997. The Rise and Fall of Culture History. New York: Plenum Press.
Marquardt, W.H. 1978. "Advances in Archaeological Seriation". In Advances in Archaeological Method and Theory, ed. Michael B. Schiffer, 257-314. Vol. 1. New York: Academic Press.
McElreath, Richard and Robert Boyd. 2007 . Mathematical Models of Social Evolution: A Guide for the Perplexed. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Mesoudi, Alex. 2011. Cultural Evolution: How Darwinian Theory Can Explain Human Culture and Synthesize the Social Sciences. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Mesoudi, Alex, Andrew Whiten and Kevin N. Laland. 2006. Towards a unified science of cultural evolution. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 29: 329-383.
Neiman, Fraser D. 1995. Stylistic Variation in Evolutionary Perspective: Inferences from Decorative Diversity and Interassemblage Distance in Illinois Woodland Ceramic Assemblages. American Antiquity 60: 7-36.
Nešić, Miloš. 2012. Arheološka kultura u evolucionističkoj perspektivi: modelovanje kulturne transmisije u kasnom neolitu Centralnog Balkana. Neobjavljen master rad odbranjen na Filozofskom fakultetu Univerziteta u Beogradu.
Nettle, Daniel and Louise Harriss. 2003. Genetic and Linguistic Affinities between Human Populations in Eurasia and West Africa. Human Biology 75(3): 331-344.
O'Brien, Michael J., John Darwent and R. Lee Lyman. 2001. Cladistics Is Useful for Reconstructing Archaeological Phylogenies: Palaeoindian Points from the Southeastern United States. Journal of Archaeological Science 28(10): 1115-1136.
O'Brien, Michael J. and R. Lee Lyman. 2003 . Cladistics and Archaeology. Salt Lake City: The University of Utah Press.
O'Brien, Michael J. and Robert L. Lyman. 1999. Seriation, Stratigraphy, and Index Fossils: The Backbone of Archaeological Dating. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum.
O'Brien, Michael J. and Robert L. Lyman. 2000. Applying Evolutionary Archaeology. New York: Plenum Press.
Ohmagari, Kayo and Fikret Berkes. 1997. Transmission of Indigenous Knowledge and Bush Skills Among the Western James Bay Cree Women of Subarctic Canada. Human Ecology 25(2): 197-222.
Olsen, Bjornar. 2002. Od predmeta do teksta. Beograd: Geopoetika.
Palavestra, Aleksandar. 2011. Kulturni konteksti arheologije. Beograd: Filozofski fakultet.
Porčić, Marko. 2006. Etnoarheologija – sadašnjost kao ključ za prošlost. Etnoantropološki problemi 1(2): 105-121.
Powell, Adam. 2009. Late Pleistocene Demography and the Appearance of Modern Human Behavior. Science 324: 1298-1301.
Read, Dwight W. 1989. Intuitive typology and automatic classification: Divergence or full circle? Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 8(2): 158-188.
Richerson, Peter J. and Robert Boyd. 2005. Not by Genes Alone: How Culture Transformed Human Evolution. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Robb, John. 1991. Random causes with directed effects: the Indo-European language spread and the stochastic loss of lineages. Antiquity 65: 287-291.
Roberts, Benjamin W. and Marc Vander Linden (eds) 2011. Investigating Archaeological Cultures: Material Culture, Variability, and Transmission. Springer. New York: Springer.
Sackett, James R. 1982. Approaches to style in lithic archaeology. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 1(1): 59-112.
Sackett, James R. 1986. Isochrestism and style: A clarification. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 5(3): 266-277.
Schiffer, Michael B. 1972. Archaeological Context and Systemic Context. American Antiquity 37: 156-165.
Schiffer, Michael B. 1975. Archaeology as Behavioral Science. American Anthropologist 77: 836-848.
Schiffer, Michael B. 1976. Behavioral Archeology. New York: Academic Press.
Schiffer, Michael B. 1987. Formation Processes of the Archaeological Record. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press.
Schiffer, Michael B. 1995. Behavioral Archaeology: First Principles. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press.
Shennan, S. J. and J. R. Wilkinson. 2001. Ceramic Style Change and Neutral Evolution: A Case Study from Neolithic Europe. American Antiquity 66(4): 577-593.
Shennan, Stephen. 2002. Genes, memes and human history: Darwinian archaeology and cultural evolution. London: Thames & Hudson.
Shennan, Stephen. 2004. Quantifying Archaeology. Edinburgh: University of Edinburgh Press.
Shennan, Stephen. 2006. "Analytical Archaeology". In A Companion to Archaeology, ed. J. Bintliff, Timothy Earle and Cristopher S. Peebles, 3-20. Oxford: Blackwell.

Shennan, Stephen. 2011. Descent with modification and the archaeological record. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 366: 1070-1079.
Spencer, Matthew, Elizabeth A. Davidson, Adrian C. Barbrook and Christopher J. Howe. 2004. Phylogenetics of artificial manuscripts. Journal of Theoretical Biology 227(4): 503-511.
Srejović, Dragoslav. 1984. "Umetnost i religija". U Vinča u praistoriji i srednjem veku, ur. Stojan Ćelić, 42-56. Beograd: SANU.
Tasić, Nikola. 1995. Eneolithic Cultures of Central and West Balkans. Belgrade: Draganić.
Tehrani, Jamshid J., Mark Collard and Stephen J. Shennan. 2010. The cophylogeny of populations and cultures: reconstructing the evolution of Iranian tribal craft traditions using trees and jungles. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, B: Biological Sciences 365: 3865-3874.
Trigger, Bruce. 1989. A history of archaeological thought. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Wiessner, Polly. 1983 . Style and Social Information in Kalahari San Projectile Points. American Antiquity 48(2): 253-276.
Wiessner, Polly. 1984 . Reconsidering the Behavioral Basis for Style: A Case Study among the Kalahari San. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 3: 190-234.
Wylie, Alison. 1982. An analogy by any other name is just as analogical. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 1: 1-34.
Published
2013-09-17
How to Cite
Porčić, Marko. 2013. “An Exercise in Theoretical Archaeology: Do Archaeological Cultures Exist?”. Issues in Ethnology and Anthropology 8 (3), 633-55. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.21301/eap.v8i3.2.