Neither “Celtic” nor “Dacian”: The Site of Židovar at the Edges of La Tène, Carpathian and Roman Worlds
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21301/eap.v16i3.8Keywords:
Židovar, late Iron Age, Roman period, connectivity, cultural localization, “Celts”, “Dacians”Abstract
The paper reviews long-standing interpretation of the late Iron Age site of Židovar as “Celtic”, “Dacian” and “Celto-Dacian”. Arguing that this standpoint is derived from biased culture-historical ethno-determinism, the evidence is reconsidered from excavation journals of Branko Gavela and published research on Židovar. Evidential basis is discussed, such as sratigraphic difficulties and chronology, as well as some common misconceptions of the site’s characteristics. Deadlocks are emphasized regarding the conclusions on its ethnic belonging. The paper calls for a new approach that goes beyond ethno-cultural determinism and urges the employment of “relational locality”. This perspective considers the site and its immediate surroundings as the first order community, i.e. the spatio-social focal point entangled in diverse, multidirectional and supra-regional relational networks. This would mean that the community of Židovar actively mediated different templates coming from the “globalized” koines of La Tène Pannonian, Danubian-Carpathian and Roman worlds, and bricolaged them in distinctive local ways.
Downloads
References
Bakić, Ljiljana. 2005. „The Finds of Coins in the La Tène Settlement at Židovar, Preliminary Report“. In Acta Numismatica INCC 2004, Proceedings of the 4th International numisnmatic Congress in Croatia, Septem-ber 20–25, 2004, Stari Grad (Pharos), the island of Hvar & M/S Marko Polo, edited by Julijana Dobrinić, 11–19. Rijeka: Hrvatsko numizmatičko društvo.
Benac, Alojz, ur. 1987. Praistorija jugoslovenskih zemalja V, željezno doba. Sarajevo: Akademija nauka i um-jetnosti Bosne i Hercegovine.
Biehl, Peter F., Alexander Gramsch and Arkadiusz Marciniak, eds. 2002. Archäologien Europas: Geschichte, Methoden und Theorien/ Archeologies of Europe: History, Methods and Theories. Münster: Waxmann.
Boatwright, Mary T. 2015. „Acceptance and Approval: Romans’ Non-Roman Population Transfers, 180 B.C.E.–CA 70 C.E”. Phoenix 69/1‒2: 122‒146. https://doi.org/10.7834/phoenix.69.1–2.0122
Božič, Dragan. 1984. „O starosti konjeniškega groba št. 16 z latenskega grobišča na beograjski Karaburmi“. In Keltski voz, edited by Mitja Guštin and Ludwig Pauli, 133–139. Brežic: Posavski muzej. (in Slovenian with an English summary)
Brukner, Olga. 1981. Rimska keramika u jugoslovenskom delu provincije Donje Panonije. Beograd: Pokrajinski zavod za zaštitu spomenika kulture SAP Vojvodine, Savez arheoloških društava Jugoslavije. (In Serbian with an English summary)
Crawford, Michael F. 1974. Roman Republican Coinage I. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Crişan, Ion Horaţiu. 1969. Ceramica Daco-Getică cu speciala privire la Transilvania. Bucureşti: Editura Şti-inţifică.
Daicoviciu, Constantin. 1960. „Perioada Burebista-Decebal (sec. I i.e.n.–106 e.n.)“. In Istoria Romaniei (volu-mul 1): Comuna primitiva, sclavagismul, perioada de trecere la feudalism, edited by Constantin Daicoviciu, 255–341. Bucureşti: Editura Academiei Romane.
Dizdar, Marko. 2010. „Kantharoi of autochthonous – “Pannonian” origin from the La Tène culture cemetery in Zvonimirovo, Croatia“. In Iron Age communities in the Carpathian Basin proceedings of the international colloquium from Targu Mureş, 9–11 October 2009, edited by Sándor Berecki, 297–307. Cluj-Napoca: Edi-tura Mega.
Drăgan, Andreea. 2012. „Late Iron Age Burials in the Iron Gates Area. A Functional Approach to Funerary Expression in the Late La Tène“. In Iron Age Rites and Rituals in the Carpatian Basin. Proceedings of the International Colloquium from Târgu Mureş 7–9 October 2011, edited by Sandor Berecki, 425–451. Târgu Mureş: Editura Mega.
Drnić, Ivan. 2020. „The Scordisci A story from the verge of the La Tène world“. In Unité et diversité du monde celtique. Actes du 42e colloque international de l’Association française pour l’étude de l’âge du Fer (Pra-gue, 10–13 mai 2018), edited by Gilles Pierrevelcin, Jan Kysela and Stephan Fichlt, 425–447. Prague: Col-lection AFEAF.
Džino, Danijel. 2011. „Indigene zajednice zapadnog i središnjeg Balkanskog poluotoka i 21. stoljeće: metodo-loški problem“. Godišnjak Centra za balkanološka isispitivanja ANUBiH 40: 197–206. (in Bosnian with an English summary)
Egri, Mariana. 2014. „Enemy at the gates? Interactions between Dacians and Romans in the 1st century AD“. In The Edges of the Roman World, edited by Marko A. Janković, Vladimir D. Mihajlović and Staša Babić, 172–193. Newcastle: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
Egri, Mariana. 2019. Connectivity and Social Dynamics in the Carpathian Basin (1st century BC – 1st century AD). Cluj-Napoca: Mega Publishing House.
Feugère, Michel. 1985. Les fibules en Gaule Méridionale de la conquête à la fin du Ve s. ap. J.-C. Paris: Editi-ons du CNRS.
Gabler, Dénes. 2016. „Rheinzaberner Sigillaten in Pannonien“. Acta Archaeologica Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae 67: 115–128. https://doi.org/10.1556/072.2016.67.1.4
Garašanin, Milutin. 1953. „Iz istorije Kelta u Srbiji“. Istoriski glasnik 3–4: 3–16. (Serbian Cyrilic)
Garašanin, Milutin. 1957. „Ka problematici kasnog latena u donjem Podunavlju“. Zbornik Matice srpske za društvene nauke 18: 78–102. (Serbian Cyrilic)
Garašanin, Draga. 1964. „Osvrt na problem kontinuiteta na dako-getskoj nekropoli »Gloždar« u Paraćinu“. In Materijali VI kongresa jugoslovenskih arheologa, 1964, uredio Jovan Todorović, 79–87. Ljubljana: Savez arheoloških društava Jugoslavije. (in Serbian with a French summary)
Gavela, Branko. 1952. Keltski oppidum Židovar: prilog kulturnoj istoriji naše zemlje protoistoriskog doba. Beograd: Naučna knjiga. (in Serbian with french summary)
Gavela, Branko. 1964. „Židovar – Jasenovo, višeslojno nalazište“. Arheološki pregled 6: 39–45.
Gavela; Branko. 1966. „Židovar – višeslojno praistorijsko naselje“. Arheološki pregled 8: 38–40.
Gavela, Branko. 1970. „O etničkim problemima latenske kulture Židovara“. Starinar 20/1969: 119–127. (in Serbian with a French summary)
Gavela, Branko. 1976. „Epoha keltske kulture na Balkanu“. Zbornik Filozofskog fakulteta 13–1: 17–37. (in Serbian with French summary)
Ghenghea 2014. „The Ethnic Construction of Early Iron Age Burials in Transylvania. Scythi-ans, Agathyrsi or Thracians?“ In Fingerprinting the Iron Age: Approaches to identity in the European Iron Age. Integrating South-Eastern Europe into the debate, edited by Catalin N. Popa and Simon Stoddart, 76–88. Oxford: Oxbow Books.
Glodariu, Ioan. 1983. Arhitectura Dacilor civilă şi militară (sec. II î.e.n. — I e.n.). Cluj-Napoca: Editura Dacia.
Hajdu, Barbara. 2018. „Terra sigillata from the territory of the civil town of Brigetio“. Dissertationes Archaeo-logicae Ser. 3 No. 6: 445–460.
Hartley, Brian R. and Dickinson Brenda M., eds. 2011. Names on Terra Sigillata. Volume 8 (S to Symphorus). London: Institute of Classical Studies.
Istenič, Iskra. 2005. „Brooches of Alesia type in Slovenia“. Arheološki vestnik 56: 187–212.
Janković, Marko. 2014. „Negotiating Identities at the Edge of the Roman Empire“. In Fingerprinting the Iron Age: Approaches to identity in the European Iron Age. Integrating South-Eastern Europe into the debate, edited by Cătălin N. Popa and Simon Stoddart, 89‒96. Oxford: Oxbow Books.
Jevtić, Miloš. 1997. „Židovar in the Early Iron Age“. In Židovar: Bronze Age and Iron Age settlement, edited by Miroslav Lazić, 38–51. Belgrade-Vršac: Faculty of Philosophy Belgrade and the National Museum of Vršac.
Jevtić, Miloš. 2006. „Character of Finds and Chronology“; „Concluding discussion“. In The Židovar Treasure, edited by Miloš Jevtić, Miroslav Lazić and Miodrag Sladić, 82–16; 167–170. Vršac-Belgrade: The City Museum of Vršac and Faculty of Philosophy Belgrade.
Jevtić, Miloš, Miroslav Lazić and Miodrag Sladić. 2006. The Židovar Treasure. Vršac-Belgrade: the City Mu-seum of Vršac and Faculty of Philosophy Belgrade.
Jevtić, Miloš and Marija Ljuština. 2008. „Dacian Pottery from Židovar“. In The Iron Gates Region during the Second Iron Age: Settlements, Necropolises, Treasures, Proceedings of the International Colloquium from Drobeta-Turnu Severin June 12th-15th, 2008, edited by Valeriu Sîrbu and Ion Stîngă, . Drobeta-Turnu Se-verin: Mehedinţi County Council, Drobeta Turnu Severin “Iron Gates” Museum.
Jevtić, Miloš and Miodrag Sladić. 1999. „Some stratigraphic issues of the Iron Age settlements at Židovar“. In Le Djerdap/les Portes de Fer a la deuxieme moitie du premier millenaire av. J. Ch. jusqu’aux guerres Da-ciques. Kolloquium in Kladovo–Drobeta-Turnu Severin (September–October 1998), edited by Miloje Vasić, 94–100. Beograd: Jugoslawisch – Rumänische Kommission für die Erforschung der Region des Eisernen Tores.
Jovanović, Aleksandar. 1997. „Židovar in the Roman period“. In Židovar: Bronze Age and Iron Age settlement, edited by Miroslav Lazić, 69–79. Belgrade-Vršac: Faculty of Philosophy Belgrade and the National Muse-um of Vršac.
Jovanović, Borislav. 1974. „Mlađe gvozdeno doba“;,,Metalurgija gvožđa protoistorijskog perioda.“ In: Prais-torija Vojvodine, uredili Bogdan Brukner, Borislav Jovanović i Nenad Tasić, 277–316; 329–336. Novi Sad: Institut za izučavanje istorije Vojvodine i Savez arheoloških društava Jugoslavije.
Jovanović, Borislav. 1979. „Značenje dačke keramike na naseljima Skordiska u Podunavlju“. Starinar 28–29: 9–17. (in Serbian with a French summary)
Jovanović, Borislav. 1991. „Skordisci i dako-getska keramika Podunavlja“. Zbornik filozofskog fakulteta 17: 151–160. (in Serbian with an English summary)
Jovanović, Borislav. 2018. Early La Tène Pećine Necropolis. Belgrade: Institute of Archaeology.
Jovanović, Borislav and Marija Jovanović. 1988. Gomolava, naselje mlađeg gvozdenog doba. Novi Sad i Beo-grad: Vojvođanski muzej i Arheološki institut. (in Serbian with an English summary)
Jovanović, Marija. 1992. „Židovar“. In Scordisci and the Autochthons: Scordisci and the Native Population in the Middle Danube Region, edited by Nikola Tasić. Belgrade: SASA, Institute for Balkan Studies.
Jovanović, Marija. 2008. „Utvrđeno kasnolatensko utvrđenje Čarnok kod Vrbasa (pregled istraživanja od 1984. do 2007. godine)“. Rad Muzeja Vojvodine 50: 61–78.
Kuzmanović, Zorica and Ivan Vranić. 2014. „On the reflexive nature of archaeologies of the Western Balkan Iron Age: a case study of the „Illyrian argument““. Anthropologie (Brno) 51(2): 249–259.
Lazić, Miroslav, ed. 1997. Židovar: Bronze Age and Iron Age settlement. Belgrade-Vršac: Faculty of Philo-sophy Belgrade and the National Museum of Vršac.
Lazić, Miroslav. 2006. „Character of Finds and Chronology“;,,Concluding discussion“. In The Židovar Treasu-re, edited by Miloš Jevtić, Miroslav Lazić and Miodrag Sladić, 82–16; 167–170. Vršac-Belgrade: The City Museum of Vršac and Faculty of Philosophy Belgrade.
Ljuština, Marija. 2011. „Rotary quern from Židovar – a glimpse into Late Iron Age economy“. In The Eastern Celts: the Communities between the Alps and the Black Sea, edited by Mitja Guštin and Miloš Jevtić, 143–149. Koper – Beograd: Univerza na Primorskem, Znanstveno-raziskovalno središče Koper, Založba Annales – Univerzitet u Beogradu, Filozofski fakultet.
Ljuština, Marija. 2014. „La Tene Settlement Židovar near Vršac, Serbia“. In The Clash of Cultures? The Celts and the Macedonian World, edited by Mitja Guštin and Wolfgang David, 217–224. Manching: Kelten Römer Museum Manching.
Lockyear, Kris. 2004. „The Late Iron Age background to Roman Dacia“. In Roman Dacia: the making of a Pro-vincial Society, edited by W. S. Hanson and I. P. Haynes, 33–74. Portsmouth, Rhode Island: The Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies.
Massey, Doreen. 2005. For Space. London: SAGE.
Medović, Aleksandar. 2003. „Archäobotanische Untersuchungen in der metallzeitlichen Siedlung Židovar, Vojvodina/Jugoslawien. Ein Vorbericht“. Starinar, 52: 181–190.
Mihajlović, Vladimir D. 2014. „Tracing ethnicity backwards: the case of the ‘Central Balkan Tribes’“. In Fin-gerprinting the Iron Age: Approaches to identity in the European Iron Age. Integrating South-Eastern Eu-rope into the debate, edited by Cătălin N. Popa and Simon Stoddart, 97‒107. Oxford: Oxbow Books.
Mihajlović, Vladimir D. 2018. „Imagining the Ister / Danube in Ancient Thought and Practice: River, the Scor-disci, and Creation of Roman Imperialistic Space“. Etnoantropološki problemi 13/3: 747–780. https://doi.org/10.21301/eap.v13i3.10
Mihajlović, Vladimir D. 2019. Skordisci između antičkih i modernih tumačenja: pitanje identiteta u (pro-to)istoriji. Novi Sad: Filozofski fakultet. (in Serbian with an English summary)
Mihajlović, Vladimir D. 2020. „Confusing Iron Ages: Communities of the middle Danube region between “tri-bal hierarchy” and heterarchy“. In Alternative Iron Ages: Social Theory from Archaeological Analysis, edi-ted by Ines Sastre and Brias X. Currás, 218–256. London: Routledge.
Mongardi, Manuela. 2014. L’instrumentum fittile inscriptum della colonia romana di Mutina e del suo territo-rio, PhD Thesis. Bologna: Università di Bologna.
Palavestra, Aleksandar. 2020. Usamljeni arheolog: Terenski metod Miloja M. Vasića. Beograd: Filozofski fa-kultet.
Papazoglu, Fanula. 1978. The Central Balkan Tribes in pre-Roman Times: Triballi, Autariatae, Dardanians, Scordisci and Moesians. Amsterdam: Adolf M. Hakkert.
Plantos, Cristinel. 2019. „A “Langton-Down”-Type Fibula from the Late Latène Settlement in Craiva-Piatra Craivii (Alba County)“. Terra Sebus. Acta Musei Sabesiensis 11: 223–243.
Plantos, Cristinel and Marius-Mihai Ciută. 2016. „Two belt buckles of Late Latène period from Craiova – “Pia-tra Craivii” – recently recovered“. Apvlvm 53: 165–177.
Popa, Catalin Nicolae. 2018. Modeling Identities: A Case Study from the Iron Age of South-East Europe. Cham: Springer.
Popa, Cătălin Nicolae and Simon Stoddart, eds. 2014. Fingerprinting the Iron Age: Approaches to identity in the European Iron Age. Integrating South-Eastern Europe into the debate. Oxford: Oxbow Books.
Popović, Petar. 1992. „The Scordisci from the fall of Macedonia to the Roman conquest“. In Scordisci and the Autochthons: Scordisci and the native Population in the Middle Danube Region, edited by Nikola Tasić, 35‒52. Belgrade: Serbian Academy of Sciences and Arts, Institute for Balkan Studies.
Popović, Petar. 2000. „La céramique de LaTène finale sur les territoires des Scordisques (Ier siècle av n. è.– Ier siècle de n. è.)“. Starinar 50: 83–111.
Popović, Petar. 2005. „“cum a Scordiscis Dacisque premeretur...”“. In Celts on the Margin. Studies in Europe-an Cultural Interaction 7th Century BC –1st Century AD, Dedicated to Zenon Woźniak, edited by H. Dobr-zańska, V. Megaw, P. Poleska, 77–84. Krakow: Institute of Archaeology and Ethnology of the Polish Aca-demy of Sciences.
Popović, Petar. 2014. „Balkan kantharoi“. In Celtic Art in Europe: Making Connections, edited by Christopher Gosden, Sally Crawford and Katharina Ulmschneider, 177–182. Oxford: Oxbow Books.
Preda, Constantin. 1973. Monedele Geto-Dacilor. Bucareşti: Editura Academiei Republicii Socialiste Romania. (in Romanian with a German summary)
Pupeză, Luca-Paul. 2010. „Ceramica daco-getică din interiorul arcului Carpatic (sfarşitul sec. III a. Chr. – ince-putul sec. I a. Chr.)“. Revista Bistriţei 24: 129–162.
Pupeză, Luca-Paul. 2012. Veacul Întunecat al Daciei. Cluj-Napoca: Editura Mega. (in Romanian with an En-glish summary)
Radišić, Teodora. 2017. „Arheologija pejzaža kasnog latena južne Panonije: perspektive i mogućnosti analiza stabilnih izotopa“. Etnoantropološki problemi 12/3: 749–765. (in Serbian with an English summary). https://doi.org/10.21301/eap.v12i3.4
Radišić, Teodora and Marija Ljuština. (in print) „Animal Husbandry and Hunting in Late La Tène Settlement at the Site of Židovar, Banat, Serbia, Demonstrated by Results of Analysis of Animal Remains from 1977 Excavation Campaign“. Istros 26.
Riha, Emilie. 1979. Die römische Fibeln aus Augst und Kaiseraugst. Augst: Forshungen in Augst Band 3.
Rustoiu, Aurel. 1997. Fibulele din Dacia Preromană (sec. II ȋ.e.n.– I e.n.). Bucureşti: Institutl Român de Traco-logie.
Rustoiu, Aurel. 2005. „Die dakischen befestigten Siedlungen im Gebiet der Eisernen Tore der Donau (2. Jh.v.Chr.–1. Jh.n.Chr.)“. In Limes Dacicus Occidentalis, Eduard Nemeth, Aurel Rustoiu and Horea Pop, 60–77. Cluj-Napoca: Editura Mega
Rustoiu, Aurel and Mariana Egri. 2010. „Danubian kantharoi – almost three decades later“. In Iron Age com-munities in the Carpathian Basin proceedings of the international colloquium from Targu Mureş, 9–11 Oc-tober 2009, edited by Sándor Berecki, 217–287. Cluj-Napoca: Editura Mega.
Rustoiu, Aurel and Iosif Vasile Ferencz. 2018. „Burebista at the Banat’s Danube. Archaeological and Historical Data regarding the Evolution of Settlements in the Iron Gates Region in the 1st Century BC“. Banatica 28: 123–149.
Rustoiu, Aurel, Iosif Vasile Ferencz and Andreea Drăgan. 2017. „Dacian fortified settlements in the Iron Gates region during Late Iron Age (2nd Century BC–1st Century AD)“. In Iron Age fortifications on the Tisa-Dniester space, Proceedings of Saharna Summer Colloquium July 14th-17th, 2016, edited by Aurel Zanoci, Valeriu Sirbu and Mihail Băţ, 187–208. Brăila: Editura Istros a Muzeului Brăilei “Carol I”.
Rusu-Bolindet, Viorica. 2005. „New data on the imported terra sigillata from Napoca“. Acta Musei Napocen-sis. I, Preistorie, istorie veche, arheologie 41–42 (2004–2005): 195–250.
Sladić, Miodrag. 1986. Keramika Skordiska. Latenska keramika u ugoslovenskom Podunavlju. Beograd: Centar za arheološka istraživanja FF UBG. (in Serbian with English summary)
Sladić, Miodrag. 1991. „Latenski sloj na Židovaru. Osvrt na arheološka iskopavanja 1977“. Zbornik Filozof-skog fakulteta u Beogradu 17: 137–150. (in Serbian with a French summary)
Sladić, Miodrag. 1997. „Židovar in the Late Iron Age“. In Židovar: Bronze Age and Iron Age settlement, edited by Miroslav Lazić, 55–66. Belgrade-Vršac: Faculty of Philosophy Belgrade and the National Museum of Vršac.
Tasić, Nikola, ed. 1992. Scordisci and the Autochthons: Scordisci and the Native Population in the Middle Da-nube Region. Belgrade: SASA, Institute for Balkan Studies.
Thér, Richard, Tomáš Mangel and Miloš Gregor. 2017. „Potter’s Wheel in the Iron Age in Central Europe: Process or Product Innovation?“. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory 24: 1256–1299. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10816–016–9312–0
Todorović, Jovan 1974. Skordisci: istorija i kultura. Novi Sad i Beograd: Institut za izučavanje istorije Vojvo-dine i Savez arheoloških društava Jugoslavije. (in Serbian with an English summary)
Uzelac, Jovan. 1997. „History of Research.“ In Židovar: Bronze Age and Iron Age settlement, edited by Miro-slav Lazić, 11–18. Belgrade-Vršac: Faculty of Philosophy Belgrade and the National Museum of Vršac.
Van Oyen, Astrid. 2016. „Historicising Material Agency: from Relations to Relational Constellations“. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory 23: 354–378. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10816–015–9244–0
Varien, Mark D. and James M. Potter. 2008. „The Social Production of Communities: Structure, Agency and Identity“. In The Social Production of Communities: Structure, Agency and Identity in the Prehispanic Southwest, edited by Mark D. Varien and James M. Potter, 1–18. Lanham: Altamira Press.
Werz, Ulrich. 2009. Gegenstempel auf Aesprägungen der frühen römischen Kaiserzeit im Rheingebiet – Grundlagen, Systematik, Typologie – Teil II. Katalog. Winterthur.
Živković, Jelena, Thilo Rehren, Miljana Radivojević, Miloš Jevtić and Dragan Jovanović. 2014. „XRF Charac-terisation of Celtic Silver from Židovar Treasure (Serbia)“. In Under the Volcano: Proceedings of the In-ternational Symposium on the Metallurgy of the European Iron Age (SMEIA) held in Mannheim, Germany, 20–22 April 2010, edited by Ernst Pernicкa and Roland Schwab, 157–173. Rahden/Westf.: Verlag Marie Leidorf GmbH.
Abbreviations
ŽEJ – Židovar Excavation Journals, Unpublished field documentation kept in the Archaeological collection of Faculty of Philosophy, University of Belgrade.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2021 Vladimir D. Mihajlović, Marko A. Janković
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
ERIH PLUS - European Reference Index for the Humanities
World Cat
AnthroSerbia
